Mikey's Late Night Slice

Mikey's Late Night Slice is a delightful pizza haven tucked away at 268 S 4th St in Columbus, OH, where the culinary experience transcends mere dining. Customers rave about the atmosphere, with decor that exudes fun and nostalgia, setting the perfect backdrop for a casual bite. A standout feature is the staff, consistently described as friendly and attentive, ensuring that every visit feels special. The poignant touch of complimentary food for patrons celebrating milestones, like a birthday, is a testament to their exceptional customer service.

The menu, while diverse, never disappoints; the pepperoni pizza is a fan favorite, boasting a crust that is perfectly cooked and toppings that deliver flavor in every bite. For those seeking something unique, the Mushroom Kingdom pie with its savory sauce and fresh ingredients has been noted as "an absolute banger." The addition of complementary sauces, especially the adventurous Unicorn Sauce, adds an exciting twist to the experience.

Whether you're in for a casual slice, a late-night craving, or a celebratory meal, Mikey's Late Night Slice encapsulates everything one hopes for in a pizzeria: great food, an inviting atmosphere, and a staff that treats you like family. A must-visit for both locals and out-of-towners alike!

From the business
- Identifies as Latino-owned
Service options
- Outdoor seating
- No-contact delivery
- Delivery
- Takeaway
- Dine-in
Highlights
- Fast service
- Great beer selection
- Great cocktails
Popular for
- Lunch
- Dinner
- Solo dining
Accessibility
- Wheelchair-accessible car park
- Wheelchair-accessible entrance
- Wheelchair-accessible seating
- Wheelchair-accessible toilet
Offerings
- Alcohol
- Beer
- Cocktails
- Comfort food
- Happy-hour drinks
- Late-night food
- Quick bite
- Spirits
- Vegan options
- Vegetarian options
- Wine
Dining options
- Lunch
- Dinner
- Catering
- Dessert
- Seating
- Table service
Amenities
- Bar on site
- Gender-neutral toilets
- Toilet
- Wi-Fi
- Wi-Fi
Atmosphere
- Casual
- Cosy
- Trendy
Crowd
- Family friendly
- Groups
- LGBTQ+ friendly
- Tourists
- Transgender safe space
- University students
Planning
- Accepts reservations
Payments
- Credit cards
- Debit cards
- NFC mobile payments
- Credit cards
Children
- Good for kids
- High chairs
Parking
- Free of charge street parking
- Paid parking lot
- Paid street parking
- Parking

Rx7R4C3R

Jun 24,2025

Twas a great day, stopped by while traveling and thought we'd try some crazy hotdogs, fast forward 30 minutes and it was ok but meh enough to still be hungry. So we parked just next mikeys and it looked nice and had a very alluring scent coming from it. This is a wed. So not really busy. I decide I need some good food still. I walk in and the atmosphere and decor is just awesome vibes and fun emotions are wild. Very pleasant young gentlemen working in 4-16-25 evening shift, so great to interact with and I decided to try the plain ass pepperoni and grab a drink. We mention it's my birthday and he goes into extra awesome mode and says it's on the house and I am just in awe do you hear me, this is unheard of now a days, a very cool touch of respect . And to beat it all the pizza is fan freaking tastic!! Great crust amd toppings are actually toppings for every bite. Fan favorite for life now when I visit cbus!!! THANK YOU very much for my wonderful experience and we will fornsure be back to one of your locations again and many times after!!! For anyone else who made it this far just give the place a try, I don't think you'll be disappointed as long as you enjoy great pizza and great atmosphere!

ramon Sykes

Jun 10,2025

For a sunday night, I could not have imagined a better place to visit!!! Friendly employees, great food and drinks. And let's not talk about the 80s music marathon the Queen Tessa started!! I ate an entire pizza by myself!

Taylor Edwards

May 2,2025

We ordered ahead on valentines days 2025. The pizza was shaped as a heart, so cute and great effort. They messed up our pizza order and we’re gunna give us a brand new one and let us keep the one they messed up on. So generous and wow just nice of them to do that. It’s the best pizza I’ve had in Columbus!!

Matthew Harris

Apr 29,2025

First stop when I got to town. Cashier was friendly, welcoming, and helpful for a first timer. He answered my questions and offered advice to help decide. I went with the special mushroom Kingdom pie Togo which was an absolute banger. The sauce was delicious, good meaty Mushrooms, good flavor, well cooked crust! Over all a delicious well made pie. As an out of towner not knowing what to expect they certainly set the bar high for the rest of the restaurants I’ll visit while in town.

Natalie Dorsey

Apr 11,2025

Mushroom with Roasted Garlic by the slice is my go-to every time. It never disappoints Love the NY-style crust—larger slice and foldable. Don’t forget the Unicorn Sauce! I opted for the spicy version this time which is similar to a spicy mayo, but more interesting! Really enjoy the more classic music hits they have playing over the sound system. It provides an entire mood which matches the taste offerings. Not to mention the decor. At this location they have a full bar, if interested. I stopped in on a Wednesday towards the end of lunch to dine-in and there was only one other patron who ordered something. Just got a slice dipping sauce and it was under 6.

JozARTSY

Apr 10,2025

The best pizza we’ve ever eaten. yes 70 million views. Do you have a problem? I don’t know I would have to look at my first and see if it was a bad one or a place and I was like give them a review or maybe just like taking pictures of my food and then one day I was like I’m gonna post it on there so it’s downtown. It’s like I don’t know if it’s vegan or vegetarian but it’s really good. It’s kind of I wanna say Asian food but like healthy really good anyway I posted a picture of their lobby like it was a stupid picture and it got like 2 million views and I was like what the heck like this place in Louisville like that’s what that’s what maybe you want to start cause I was like people are looking at it so.

Jennifer Price

Mar 12,2025

I so so wish we had a place like Mikey's Late Night Slice around me! The pizza was delicious. The place itself was so fun. The atmosphere was great. It was affordable, and the slices are huge. Best of all, individual pizza slices available late into the night. We'll be back!

Julia Werner

Mar 5,2025

This place is so awesome! The whole environment is one of a kind, from the whole vibe of the place in general to the badass decor, everything was unlike any of pizza place I’ve ever been to. The pizza was a little bit greasy, but it suits it well considering the pizza slices are GIANT! Definitely a nice size piece that’s perfect for folding!

Amenities and More

Photos

Reviews For Mikey's Late Night Slice

Add a Review

Location

Appreciated by Others